Definition
Although facial pain of various types was
mentioned in earlier medical publications, the characteristic features of
trigeminal neuralgia (tic douloureux) are as follows. The patient
experiences pain, usually severe, that occurs suddenly and lasts ordinarily
from a few seconds to less than a minute. The pain is described as
lancinating or electrical in quality, although after repetitions of such
pain the sufferer may experience a more constant aching background
discomfort. The pain is confined within the distribution of the trigeminal
nerve on one side, it more frequently involves the lower face than the
forehead and eye, and it more commonly involves the right side of the face
than the left. The pain may begin spontaneously or may begin if a "trigger
spot" on the skin of the face or within the mouth is stimulated by a touch,
a gust of wind, a cold or hot liquid, etc. It may also be set off by
speaking, chewing, or other facial movements. Trigeminal neuralgia typically
recurs in paroxysms. The victim may be bothered by a series of irregularly
occurring episodes of pain over days or weeks and then enjoy a pain-free
period of days to months. In general. the periods of pain become more
frequent with time. and pain that begins in one trigeminal division may
spread to involve a larger area of the face. Bilateral trigeminal neuralgia
can occur (in about 3 to 6 percent of cases). but the person usually has
pain on one side for a period of time and then on the other. rather than
being affected by simultaneous bilateral tic pain.
Trigeminal neuralgia is a characteristic
symptom (not a disease). as just described. that affects women more than men
in a ratio that has varied from 2: 1 to 4:3 in reported series. More than 70
percent of patients with trigeminal neuralgia are over 50 years of age when
the disorder appears. Yet, despite its uniformity of clinical presentation.
trigeminal neuralgia has been linked to a variety of etiologic agents and
possible pathophysiologic mechanisms.
In most patients with trigeminal neuralgia
the neurological examination is normal. However. there may be deficits that
provide a clue to the specific underlying disease process giving rise to
this type of facial pain. For example. the patient who has trigeminal
neuralgia on the basis of multiple sclerosis may have neurological deficits
resulting from involvement of other areas of the nervous system by the
plaques of multiple sclerosis.
Etiology and Pathogenesis
It has long been known that tic douloureux
may begin after a dental procedure in the same area of the mouth and may be
misdiagnosed at first (e.g.. a "dry socket" after tooth extraction). More
commonly. the pain begins spontaneously in the region of the upper or lower
teeth on one side. and the patient seeks dental treatment with the
assumption that the pain is of dental origin.
During the first week after the surgical
treatment of tic douloureux by one technique or another. the patient may
develop the lesions of herpes simplex on the face. typically about the mouth
and especially on the side of the previous tic pain. This has led to the
postulation that tic douloureux represents a smoldering herpetic infection
of the trigeminal ganglion or peripheral trigeminal branches. The possible
relation of tic douloureux to dental disease has also focused attention on
the peripheral portion of the trigeminal system. as have occasional case
reports of the occurrence of tic in patients with various lesions (e.g..
meningioma. epidermoid cyst. pituitary adenoma. carcinoma. aneurysm, etc.)
affecting the gasserian ganglion or one or more of the trigeminal divisions.
It is therefore natural that some of the initial attempts at treatment of tic
douloureux involved the destruction of the "involved" branch by the
injection of an agent such as ethyl alcohol or by surgical division or
avulsion of the branch. However, such approaches have not shed light on the
pathophysiology of the condition and have not provided a cure.
Further experience showed
that in some patients with trigeminal neuralgia the trigeminal nerve is
affected by a pathologic process at some point between the gasserian
ganglion and the pons. For example, the trigeminal sensory root may be
compressed and distorted by changes in the configuration of the base of the
skull, as in Paget's disease, or by a benign neoplasm or lesion within the
cerebellopontine angle (e.g., meningioma, epidermoid cyst, vestibular
schwannoma, or arteriovenous malformation). Such benign
cerebellopontine angle tumors may be found in as many as 5 to 8 percent of patients
who present with tic douloureux. Frequently the tumor will give
rise to symptoms and signs in addition to trigeminal neuralgia, such as
reduced hearing in the ipsilateral ear or an appreciable loss of facial
sensation on the same side, that provide a clue to its presence. An early
age of onset of tic douloureux may signal a posterior fossa mass lesion such
as an epidermoid tumor.
Surgical exploration of the
cerebellopontine angle in patients with tic douloureux will frequently
disclose vascular compression of the trigeminal sensory root at its entry
into the pons (nerve root entry zone). It has been postulated that as
people age the arteries elongate and become ectatic and the brain sags more
within the skull; these two factors may
bring vessels such as the superior cerebellar artery into direct contact
with the trigeminal nerve. Dandy found such neurovascular relationships in
45 percent of 215 cases and postulated that vascular compression of the
trigeminal root is a major cause of tic
douloureux. Gardner, Jannetta, and others have pursued this idea further
and have developed microvascular decompression of the trigeminal nerve as a
form of treatment for tic douloureux.
Patients who are found to
have fifth nerve compression by adjacent vessels usually have no
neurological deficits preoperatively, although some may have a slight
decrease in sensibility over the cheek. That vascular compression is not the
sole cause of trigeminal neuralgia is attested to by the fact that such
compression is not found at operation in perhaps 10 to 15 percent of
patients who might be expected clinically to have it and that close
relations between the main trigeminal
sensory root at the pons and adjacent blood vessels may be found
at autopsy in patients who did not have tic douloureux during life.
In addition to focusing
attention on the sensory root of the trigeminal nerve as the possible key
area of involvement in tic douloureux, Gardner proposed a mechanism to
explain how nerve compression might give rise to paroxysmal pain. He
postulated that neural compression leads to irregular demyelination within
the sensory root, allowing exposed adjacent axons to come into contact,
with resultant "short-circuiting" of action potentials. Such ( "cross talk" (ephaptic
transmission) might be experienced as the lancinating
pain of tic douloureux.
There is also evidence that tic douloureux may have its origin
within the brain. For example, it has been recognized that patients with
multiple sclerosis have an increased incidence of tic douloureux, probably
because of demyelination along central trigeminal pathways. Approximately
2 to 3 percent of patients with tic will be found to have multiple
sclerosis, and about 1 percent of patients with multiple sclerosis will develop tic
douloureux. The presence of the multiple sclerosis may be
suggested by an early age of onset of the tic douloureux, by
bilateral tic, and by the symptoms and signs of lesions in other areas of
the central nervous system besides the trigeminal pathways. Support for a
central mechanism in trigeminal neuralgia can also be found in the analogy
between the paroxysmal bouts of tic pain and epileptic seizures, which have
a central origin, and the fact that some anticonvulsant medications such as
carbamazepine and phenytoin have been found to have some effect in controlling tic pain.
It is apparent from the
above that tic douloureux is a symptom that can result from any of a number
of disease processes that affect the trigeminal system. The underlying
pathophysiologic mechanisms remain obscure:
Any theory to explain the
pathogenesis of tic douloureux must take into account the paroxysmal nature
of the pain (with pain-free intervals),
the facts that trigger stimuli correspond to activation of large afferent
axons in the fifth nerve rather than the small nociceptive axons and that a
trigger area can sometimes be in a
different trigeminal division than the pain, the observation that frequently
no neurological deficit can be detected, . . , and the observation that
minor trauma to the region of the gasserian ganglion and/or sensory root can
frequently relieve the pain. Further work is required to clarify how the
various etiological factors in tic douloureux actually cause this type of
pain.
Diagnosis
The diagnosis of tic
douloureux is based on the history. Its typical features have already been
discussed. Because of the implications regarding treatment, tic douloureux
should be differentiated from other types of facial pain such as
glossopharyngeal neuralgia, postherpetic neuralgia, Raeder's syndrome,
Sluder's syndrome, geniculate neuralgia, temporomandibular joint pain,
cluster headaches, post-traumatic facial neuralgia, and pain due to disease
of dental, orbital, or sinus origin.
The physical examination and
cranial computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may
give a clue to the cause of the patient's pain. Usually,
however, these are normal and treatment is begun.
Treatment
Pharmacotherapy
The anticonvulsants
phenytoin, carbamazepine and neurontin have been found to reduce or
control the pain of tic douloureux. Dilantin is less effective.
The usual approach to the treatment of tic douloureux at the present time is
to try one of these agents; if inadequate relief or significant side effects
occur with one, the other agent is tried. Because blood levels of these
drugs have not been correlated with pain relief, Loeser has recommended that the dosage of either
drugs should be increased until pain relief is achieved. The standard dose of Dilantin
is 300 or 400 mg/day. Tegretol should be started gradually, with an initial
dose of 100 or 200 mg/day. At times, a dosage of 1200 to 1800 mg/day will be
required for pain relief.
Tegretol may cause
hematosuppression or hepatic dysfunction, so patients being treated with
this agent should have a complete blood count and liver function studies
periodically. Although Tegretol, neurontin and Dilantin are often beneficial in the
initial treatment of tic douloureux, they may lose their effectiveness with
time, and the patient may then require some form of surgical treatment.
Baclofen, clonazepam, and other medications
have also been reported to have some value in the treatment of tic
douloureux. Overall, these have not been very effective, although Lioresal may be
worth trying in patients for whom Tegretol, neurontin and/or Dilantin no longer
provide adequate relief. A low dosage of Lioresal (e.g., 5 mg tid) should
be used at first, and this should be increased as tolerated until pain
relief or a significant side effect such as excessive drowsiness is
experienced. In general, analgesic
medications are not effective in treating trigeminal neuralgia. They will
not lessen the severe paroxysms of pain appreciably without causing
significant lethargy and other undesirable side effects.
Destructive Procedures
Injections along Trigeminal
Pathways
For almost tow
centuries, localized trigeminal neuralgia has been treated by the injection of
alcohol into the appropriate peripheral portion of the trigeminal nerve,
such as the supraorbital nerve, infraorbital nerve, second trigeminal
division, or third trigeminal division. Such injections can
be given quickly in an outpatient setting, they can be repeated if the tic
returns, and although the instillation of alcohol is painful, this pain is
transient and ordinarily is well tolerated. The results of five series
reported between 1912 and 1952, involving more than 1500 patients, showed
that the average duration of pain relief was, for the supraorbital nerve,
8.5 months; for the infraorbital nerve, 12 months; for the second division,
12 months; and for the third division, 16 months. In a series
reported in 1994, the median time for pain relief was 13 months for the infraorbital
nerve and 19 months for the inferior alveolar nerve.
The main disadvantages of
peripheral alcohol injections are the temporary sensory loss or paresthesia
produced and the expected eventual recurrence of tic douloureux as the nerve
regenerates and sensation returns. In addition, temporary weakness of the
muscles of mastication is an expected side effect of an alcohol block of the
third trigeminal division, because of the close approximation of the motor
root to the mandibular nerve. Such factors have prompted Loew to state" . .
. these blocks provide only temporary relief. In the hands of experienced
neurosurgeons the thermocontrolled radiofrequency lesion of trigeminal
ganglion or root is not more extensive surgery and is as well tolerated by
elderly and medically compromised patients as alcohol injection into
peripheral trigeminal branches. In the majority of cases. . . it provides
permanent pain relief.,,
In an effort to achieve more
permanent pain relief, various physicians have injected different types of
liquids into the gasserian ganglion. Harris injected alcohol into it,
starting in 1910, and subsequently others have used different destructive
agents, such as hot water. phenol in glycerine. and phenol in wax. In 1940.
Hams reported that he had treated more than 2500 cases of trigeminal tic by
gasserian alcohol injection over a 30-year period. Among 457 patients
responding to a questionnaire sent out by Hams. 316 had not experienced
recurrent pain for a period of 3 years or more (3 to 31 years). By
attempting complete destruction of the gasserian ganglion. Hams and others
could achieve excellent pain relief with no mortality. However. the
morbidity of such a procedure was substantial. with a relatively high
percentage of postinjection paresthesia and pain in the anesthetic zone, a
10 to 15 percent incidence of neuroparalytic keratitis. and an expected
paralysis of the muscles of mastication for about 3 months. By attempting
partial gasserian destruction, several investigators found that they could
reduce the incidence of these undesirable side effects. but at the price of
less effective pain relief with an increased rate of pain recurrence. The
gasserian ganglion is seldom injected with alcohol today. because of the
development of more effective techniques with lower morbidity.
A more refined type of gasserian injection.
using glycerol, was introduced by Häkanson in
1981. The development of percutaneous trigeminal glycerol rhizolysis was a
classic example of serendipity. During the development of a stereotactic
technique for gamma irradiation of the trigeminal ganglion and root for the
treatment of trigeminal neuralgia by Häkanson
and Leksell. Häkanson used glycerol as a vehicle
to introduce tantalum dust into the trigeminal cistern. "The tantalum dust
was used to mark permanently the trigeminal cistern for the precise
stereotactic localization of the trigeminal ganglion and root. Quite
unexpectedly it was observed that the intracisternal injection of glycerol
alone rendered the patient completely free from the paroxysmal pain. . . . "
Trigeminal Branch Avulsion
(Peripheral Neurectomy)
By dividing or avulsing a peripheral branch
of the trigeminal nerve. rather than injecting it with alcohol. the surgeon
can achieve a more exact. more complete. and longer lasting effect. The
branches most amenable to such treatment are the supraorbital and
supratrochlear/infratrochlear/lacrimal nerves, the infraorbital nerve and
the inferior alveolar, lingual and mental nerves. Grantham and Segerberg
reported an average pain-free period of 33.2 months after supraorbital or
infraorbital nerve avulsion. The median pain-free periods reported by Quinn
were. for infraorbital neurectomy. 26 months: for inferior alveolar
neurectomy, 37 months: for lingual neurectomy. 38 months; and for mental
neurectomy 24 months. Such neurectomies can be performed under local
anesthesia in an outpatient setting. but frequently the patient is admitted
to the hospital for a short stay. and sometimes a general anesthetic is
used. As with alcohol injection of a peripheral branch, the main
disadvantages of peripheral neurectomy are the sensory loss produced and the
eventual return of tic douloureux as the nerve regenerates and sensation
returns.
Retrogasserian Neurotomy,
Subtemporal
For many years the standard
operative approach to trigeminal neuralgia was retrogasserian
neurotomy, which had its beginning in 1890. After it had been
demonstrated that intracranial operations could be performed successfully, two
related types of operations for tic douloureux were proposed. At first,
extirpation of the gasserian ganglion was attempted.
William Rose, in 1890, developed a procedure for the piecemeal
avulsion of the ganglion through an enlarged foramen ovale. Because
of poor exposure, frequent hemorrhage, and incomplete removal
of the ganglion, this operation proved unsatisfactory. In 1891, Frank Hartley
devised an extradural temporal approach to the gasserian ganglion to facilitate
intracranial neurotomy of the second and third trigeminal divisions. This
approach proved to be the technical key that opened the way for later advances. Six and a half months after
Hartley's first operation, and unaware of it, Fedor Krause duplicated this
operation. However, Krause carried the operation a step further in 1893 when
he first completely removed the gasserian ganglion successfully. Two years
later, he analyzed 51 gasserian ganglionectomies (performed by the
Hartley-Krause approach) which had been reported in the medical literature,
The overall mortality for these 51 cases was approximately 10 percent.
Harvey Cushing then modified the Hartley-Krause approach by minimizing
traction on and subsequent hemorrhage from the middle meningeal artery. The
result was a reduction in mortality to 5 percent by 1905. After this,
extirpation of the gasserian ganglion was abandoned in favor of the second
type of operation which had been developed for tic douloureux.
Foreseeing the probable
difficulties of gasserian ganglionectomy, Victor Horsley proposed
retrogasserian neurotomy instead. He and William Macewen worked
independently to developed such a procedure. After trial operations on monkeys
and human cadavers, Horsley in 1890 attempted avulsion of the trigeminal
root in a very ill woman who had had two previous extracranial operations
for tic douloureux. Because of the unfortunate operative death of this
patient, and the simultaneous early successes with gasserian
ganglionectomy, similar attempts at dividing the trigeminal root were abandoned temporarily, David
Ferrier (1890), William Spiller (1898), and Lewellys Barker (1900) each
proposed that section of the root might afford a
permanent cure, but it was not until 1901 that this again was attempted. In
that year, Charles Frazier performed such an operation, using the
Hartley-Krause approach to the nerve. His successes established
retrogasserian neurotomy as the operation of choice, and later refinements
minimized its morbidity and mortality.
Such refinements included
the differential sectioning of the posterior sensory root
fibers, the sparing of the motor root, and overall improvement in surgical
operations during the first half of the twentieth century. The percentage of
patients who obtained relief by subtemporal retrogasserian neurotomy ranged
from 95 to 99 percent, but operative mortality remained in the 1 to 3
percent range, tic pain recurred in 5 to 20 percent, and there was
significant morbidity from the procedure.
Retrogasserian Neurotomy,
Suboccipital
At the same time that
Frazier, Peet, and others were perfecting subtemporal retrogasserian
neurotomy, Waiter Dandy developed another surgical approach to tic
douloureux, the partial or total division of the main sensory root of the
fifth nerve near the pons through a suboccipital
craniectomy. This permitted the surgeon to spare the motor portions of the
trigeminal nerve more easily. In addition, it was found that a surprising
degree of facial and corneal sensation was retained postoperatively and
that the incidence of neuroparalytic keratitis was reduced.
With the further refinement
of surgical and anesthetic techniques and the use of the operative
microscope in neurosurgical operations, Dandy's procedure has been made
safer. It remains an effective way to deal with tic douloureux,
especially when the neurosurgeon has exposed the fifth nerve at the pons
looking for evidence of vascular compression and has not found vascular
compression of the trigeminal nerve, distortion of the nerve by an adjacent
tumor, or any other abnormality.
Trigeminal Tractotomy
In 1937 Sjoqvist introduced
a new operation for the relief of trigeminal neuralgia,
trigeminal tractotomy. This involved the surgical division of the
descending tract of the fifth nerve in the medulla oblongata. It was
designed to relieve pain while preserving touch sensation and trigeminal
motor function. However, despite subsequent refinements, including the
introduction of a stereotactic technique for producing the lesion, this
procedure has never achieved widespread use, primarily because of the
difficulty in dividing all of the descending trigeminocephalic tract and yet
not injuring important adjacent portions of the medulla (with the unwanted
production of neurological deficits such as analgesia in the distributions
of the ninth and tenth cranial nerves and second cervical nerve, loss of
pain and temperature sensation on the opposite side of the body, and
ipsilateral proprioceptive loss and ataxia).
Percutaneous Trigeminal
Radiofrequency Thermocoagulation
In the 1930s, Kirschner in
Germany developed a technique for the percutaneous
electrocoagulation of the gasserian ganglion. Various other
physicians have since modified and perfected this approach to permit
partial, precise destruction within the gasserian ganglion and sensory root.
This method avoids a general anesthetic and an open operation. This
technique is now in
widespread use, It is especially valuable (if medication is not effective)
in treating elderly persons, patients in poor general health, and patients
with multiple sclerosis.
Radiosurgery - Gamma-Knife
Since its introduction by
Leksell, stereotactically focused highenergy radiation has been
used in a relatively small number of patients with trigeminal neuralgia to
partially injure the trigeminal ganglion or sensory root. Not enough is
yet known about longterm results to permit comment on the efficacy and
complications of this form of treatment.
Nondestructive Procedures
All the procedures just discussed, from peripheral
alcohol injections to percutaneous trigeminal thermocoagulation, have in
common the destruction of some
portion of the trigeminal sensory pathways. To differing degrees, they share
the undesirable side effects and possible complications of such destruction,
which include loss of sensation, paresthesia and pain in the denervated
area (the most severe form of which is anesthesia dolorosa), and the
occasional appearance of herpes simplex lesions on the face or within the
mouth or nose during the initial postoperative period. For these reasons,
investigators over the years have tried to develop nondestructive
procedures for the successful treatment of trigeminal neuralgia.
Decompression/ Compression
Operations
In 1952, Pudenz and Shelden
reported the decompression of peripheral trigeminal
branches at the foramen ovale or foramen rotundum in 10 patients, and
Taarnhoj reported the decompression of the gasserian ganglion and posterior
trigeminal root via a subtemporal approach in 10 patients. Taarnhoj's
subsequent experience showed a 40 percent rate of recurrence of tic pain.
In 1955, Shelden and his associates began to compress or rub the ganglion
and posterior root, in the hope that such mild trauma might result in pain
relief without significant sensory impairment. Further experience by
various surgeons with subtemporal decompression/compression operations did
show a reduced incidence of sensory loss, keratitis, and paresthesia.
However, 30 to 40 percent of patients experienced some return of tic pain
(usually within the first 2 years), and among 811 patients reviewed by White
and Sweet, 184 (23 percent) had recurrences severe enough to require further
surgical treatment.
In 1978, Mullan began to
treat trigeminal neuralgia by compressing the trigeminal ganglion with a percutaneously inserted Fogarty catheter balloon that was inflated through
the foramen ovale for a short period. Twelve years later, Lichtor and
Mullan reported the outcome of 100 patients who were treated in this
fashion and followed for 1 to 10 years. Relief persisted at 5 years in 80
percent; 4 percent of the patients reported dysesthesia; virtually all
patients experienced ipsilateral trigeminal motor weakness but this resolved
within 3 months. This simple technique, which is performed under a general
anesthetic, now is being used more frequently while trigeminal glycerol rhizolysis is gradually being employed less often.
Taarnhoj performed
decompression of the trigeminal sensory root via a suboccipital craniectomy
in 20 patients between 1951 and 1959 and found that only 4 (20 percent)
experienced recurrent tic pain. Dandy previously had commented on the
frequent finding of vascular compression of the trigeminal nerve at the
pons in patients with tic and in 1959 Gardner and Miklos reported the
treatment of such vascular compression in one patient by moving the artery
away from the nerve and maintaining the separation with a pledget of
absorbable gelatin sponge. Jannetta has subsequently developed this
useful technique and discusses its current status. Microvascular decompression of the trigeminal nerve through a retromastoid
craniectomy is a nondestructive yet effective method of treating tic
douloureux. It provides pain relief in a large percentage of
patients without ordinarily causing trigeminal dysfunction, including
anesthesia dolorosa. Like Dandy's suboccipital craniectomy, Jannetta's
retromastoid approach would permit the discovery of a posterior fossa tumor
that had not been detected preoperatively.
Comparison of Results of
Surgical Treatment
In 1994, Taha and Tew
analyzed their own results and those of major representative reports in the
literature for the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia by radiofrequency
thermocoagulation, glycerol rhizolysis, balloon compression, microvascular
decompression, and partial trigeminal rhizotomy. Patients achieved a high
incidence of initial pain relief after each of these procedures. However,
microvascular decompression had the lowest rate of technical success in that
15 percent of patients underwent partial trigeminal rhizotomy instead,
either because significant vascular compression was not found or adequate
decompression could not be performed safely. Radiofrequency
thermocoagulation and microvascular decompression had the highest rates of
initial pain relief and the lowest rates of pain recurrence. Glycerol rhizolysis had the highest rate of pain recurrence. Balloon compression had
the highest rate of trigeminal motor dysfunction. Balloon compression and
microvascular decompression had the lowest rates of corneal anesthesia or
keratitis. Microvascular decompression had the lowest rates of facial
numbness and dysesthesia; all of the percutaneous procedures had similar
rates of dysesthesia. Posterior fossa exploration had the highest rates of
permanent cranial nerve deficit, intracranial hemorrhage or infarction,
perioperative morbidity, and mortality.
A Therapeutic Approach to
the Patient with Tic Douloureux
The acceptable approach to the treatment
of tic douloureux is as follows: If the history, physical examination, and
diagnostic studies show no evidence of a posterior fossa tumor, the patient
is treated initially with Tegretol or neurontin. If these are unsuccessful, Dilantin is
tried, alone or in combination with Tegretol or neurontin. Lioresal can be used as well,
depending on the response to the first three medicines.
If medical therapy fails,
the subsequent approach is based on the age of the patient and the location
of the tic. In an elderly patient or a patient in poor health, with tic
restricted to the forehead, supraorbital/supratrochlear nerve avulsion or
balloon compression of the gasserian ganglion would be my next choice of
treatment. In a similar patient with tic restricted to the cheek, alcohol injection or avulsion of the infraorbital nerve or one of
the three percutaneous procedures (but favoring balloon compression to
reduce the risk of corneal denervation). Finally, in an elderly or infirm
patient with tic in the region of the eye, in the third division, or in
multiple divisions, percutaneous trigeminal balloon compression,
radiofrequency coagulation, or glycerol injection is recommended. These same
recommendations apply to the patient of any age whose tic is related to
multiple sclerosis.
If the patient is younger
than 70 years, is in good health, and has not been helped or is no longer
helped by medication, microvascular decompression is the
treatment of choice, especially if the pain involves the area of the eye
(less possibility of producing corneal anesthesia than with a percutaneous
procedure) or the mandible (less likelihood of producing weakness of the
muscles of mastication than with a percutaneous procedure). Intraoperative
monitoring of brain stem auditory evoked potentials is used to minimize the
risk of ipsilateral deafness. If definite vascular compression is not
identified at the time of operation, the caudal half or two-thirds of the
main sensory root of the trigeminal nerve should be divided adjacent to the
pons. An alternative approach (which is actually the preferred choice of
many authorities) in the healthy patient less
than 70 years of age who has pain despite an adequate trial of medical
therapy is percutaneous trigeminal balloon compression, radiofrequency
thermocoagulation, or glycerol injection.
If pain recurs after any of
these procedures, it should be approached therapeutically as a new event,
beginning with a trial of medication. Alcohol injection, nerve avulsion,
balloon compression, radiofrequency coagulation, gamma-knife and glycerol injection can
be repeated, but recurrence after microvascular decompression is probably
best approached by a percutaneous technique or by partial division of the
sensory root at the pons rather than by a second microvascular
decompression.
Whether it is to treat
initial trigeminal neuralgia or recurrent trigeminal neuralgia, the
neurosurgeon must bear in mind that there can be serious complications from
the percutaneous procedures and from posterior fossa exploration. As
reported by Sweet he and Poletti collected complication data from a
number of neurosurgeons and found the incidence and variety of such
untoward events to be greater than expected based on reports published in
the medical literature. As a general rule, the treating neurosurgeon will
obtain the best results with the approach that he or she uses most
frequently.
|